- Judge Ballots 2015 (Northwesern vs. Michigan)
- Judge Ballots 2014 (Georgetown vs. Michigan)
- Judge Ballots 2013 (Emporia vs. Northwestern)
- Judge Ballots 2012 (Georgetown vs. Northwestern)
- Judge Ballots 2011 (Northwestern vs. Emory)
- Judge Ballots 2010 (Michigan State vs. Northwestern)
- Judge Ballots 2009 (Kansas vs. Wake Forest)
- Judges Ballots 2008 (Wake Forest vs. Dartmouth)
- Judges Ballots 2007 (Emory vs. UMKC)
- Judges Ballots 2006 (Michigan State vs. Wake Forest)
- Judge Ballots 2005 (Northwestern vs. Cal Berkeley)
- Judges Ballots 2003 (Northwestern vs. Dartmouth)
- Ballots 2002 (Northwestern vs. Kentucky)
- Ballots 2001 (Iowa vs. Emory)
- Ballots 2000 (Emory vs. Michigan State)