The
Best of 1980s
By
William Southworth, University of Redlands
|
|
While each decade produces its own unique occurrences,
the 1980's seemed especially significant. The decade began with
the first unanimous final round decision when Northwestern gained some
revenge on Harvard for their 1979 final round loss. However, before
the decade would end there would be three more such unanimous final
round decisions. Going into the 1980s there had only been three undefeated
preliminary round teams, but by 1989 there were four more including
an amazing 8-0 with 24 ballots and ultimate 12-0 record.
Streaks were continued
as Harvard qualified for the NDT each year of the decade stretching
its string to thirty-six consecutive years, but Northwestern failed
to qualify in 1981 after winning in 1980 breaking its twenty-two year
stretch. But no one managed to establish streaks in the 1980's like
Dartmouth. It was possible to qualify twenty teams during the decade,
Dartmouth did that; they managed to get fourteen of those twenty teams
by First Round At-Large Bids and they sent sixteen of those twenty into
the elimination rounds of the NDT. Perhaps more amazing, Dartmouth had
at least one team in the quarter-finals of every NDT during the decade,
they had at least one team in eight of the semi-finals during the decade,
and in half of the final rounds Dartmouth was competing for the national
championship - an honor they won twice. Dartmouth's total win-loss record
for the 1980's at the NDT was an unbelievable 150-52, and that was handicapped
by the fact that twice Dartmouth was forced to forfeit rounds because
of elimination pairings of two Dartmouth teams.
There are probably
three important criteria to consider when attempting to measure the
overall BEST for a particular year, the First Round At-Large Rankings,
the NDT Preliminary Round Seeding, and the NDT Final Results. The following,
year by year breakdown, provides
that very information for your examination and comparison.
This review of
the decade finds Dartmouth listed nine times, with only Baylor even
close with five listings. Clearly it was Dartmouth's decade, a dominance
which had never been equaled and one which was clearly recognized by
the forensic community. In responding to a 1989 survey, coaches were
asked to rank their Top Five in every category, points were then allocated
(5 for first, 4 for second, etc.). Following are the listings, total
points, and the total number of first place rankings, as well as the
total number of ballots they were ranked on out of the thirty-one possible.
As in the Best of the 1970's there seemed to be consensus on most categories.
|
The Best Debaters of the
1980s
Lenny
Gail, Dartmouth |
(16 Firsts/24)
|
Lyn
Robbins, Baylor |
(6 Firsts/25)
|
Steve
Mancuso, Kentucky |
(2 Firsts/10)
|
Danny
Povinelli, Mass |
( /11)
|
Jeff
Jones, Kentucky |
(1 First/11)
|
This was justifiably one
of the closest categories with Lenny Gail edging Lyn Robbins. Unfortunately
their peak years did not overlap, unlike the 1970's where Tom Rollins
and Robert Feldhake were taking turns being first and second speakers
for a four year period. Of course, Lenny did not compete his senior
year so his opportunities were more limited. He did however, maximize
his limited NDT appearances as the next category would suggest.
|
The Best Teams of the 1980s
Gail
& Koulogeorge, Dartmouth |
(16 Firsts/24)
|
Robbins
& Vincent, Baylor |
(4 Firsts/15)
|
Jones
& Mancuso, Kentucky |
(3 Firsts/16)
|
Bredehoft
& Foutz, Harvard |
(3 Firsts/16)
|
Gidley
& Payne, Kansas |
( /11)
|
This category was not particularly
close, in 1984 Gail and Koulogeorge were 8-0 with 24 ballots and went
on to win the NDT in undefeated fashion. What is perhaps more amazing
is, that they perhaps should have done it the year before as sophomores.
They were again 8-0, not quite with 24 ballots however, and were paired
against their other team in the semis. If Ken Strange made a mistake
in the 1980s it might have been in sending the seniors on, after Gail
and Koulogeorge had defeated the same Kansas team in the prelims on
the same side Dartmouth would lose in the finals. It is perhaps that
knowledge and the fact that Gail and Koulogeorge retired after their
junior years which prompted the voters to overwhelmingly place them
first. Robbins and Vincent were only a team their senior year. During
the interceding years Lyn Robbins debated with Mark Dyer and undoubtedly
split the votes as they were ranked on six ballots for a total of 18
points. But it would be difficult to argue with Gail and Koulogeorge,
destiny may have played a part as they debated each other in the finals
of NFL Nationals their senior year in high school with Koulogeorge from
Glenbrook South defeating Gail from Maine East. They then closed out
the Novice Nationals Tournaments as freshmen before finally being paired
as sophomores for their historic streak!
|
BEST TOURNAMENT OF THE DECADE
The 1980s found some other
categories making changes, namely in the BEST TOURNAMENT OF THE DECADE.
Here respondents simply listed thier top five hosts of NDT tournaments
during the decade, from teh 1970s Heart of America was replaced as number
one and the NDT itslef moved up to number two:
WAKE
FOREST |
Dixie
Classic |
(12 Firsts/27)
|
THE
NDT |
|
(8 Firsts/21)
|
NORTHWESTERN |
Owen
Coon |
(1 First/21)
|
KANSAS |
Heart
of America |
(5 Firsts/20)
|
DARTMOUTH |
The
Great Freezeout |
(1 First/14)</TD
|
Dartmouth did regain its
number one standing in the results of the TOP NDT HOSTS.
DARTMOUTH
|
1986 |
(17
Firsts/31) |
GONZAGA
|
1985 |
(4
Firsts/15) |
UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA
|
1980 |
(6
Firsts/17) |
UNIVERSITY OF TENNESSEE
|
1984
|
(
/19) |
CSU POMONA
|
1981
|
(1
First/16) |
|
There was no real consensus on THE BEST TOPIC OF THE
DECADE, but clearly the forensic community prefers international
topics with the following ranking from first to fifth: SPACE (1984-85),
NATO (1987-88), INTERVENTION IN WESTERN HEMISPHERE (1982-83), FIRST
AMENDMENT (1986-87), and INCREASE FOREIGN MILITARY COMMITMENTS (1980-81).
|
It should come as no surprise
that Ken Strange was the overwhelming selection as BEST COACH, the preceding
statistics and categories provide rather compelling evidence to his
accomplishments. Even before assuming the coaching duties at Dartmouth
in 1981 Ken had established himself at Augustana College in Illinois,
first as an assistant with an equally impressive record accumulated
by Robert Feldhake and Rick Godfrey and later with his own teams from
Augustana, qualifying both teams at the 1980 NDT and has, as the introduction
to this article suggested, dominated the National Tournament in truly
remarkable fashion. Nor is it surprising to find Donn Parson in the
number two slot, Kansas has been among the top five NDT programs for
the twenty odd years Donn has been coach there. He is the only repeater
from the 1970s Best and only his retirement from coaching in 1988 will
prevent him from being found in the Best of the 1990s. Taking that charge
will be his successor "Robin" Rowland who was at Baylor the first half
of the decade leading them to their national title in 1987 before taking
over at Kansas where he promptly got two teams to the quarters of the
1989 NDT.
Ken
Strange, Dartmouth |
126 |
(21 Firsts/27)
|
Donn
Parson, Kansas |
61 |
(5 Firsts/ 19)
|
Dallas
Perkins, Harvard |
51 |
|
Robert
Rowland, Baylor/Kansas |
37 |
(2 Firsts/15)
|
Roger
Solt, Kentucky |
33
|
|
|
The Best Judge of the 1980s
Roger
Solt, Kentucky |
70 |
(8 Firsts/17)
|
Ken
Strange, Dartmouth |
69 |
(8 Firsts/20)
|
Dallas
Perkins, Harvard |
46 |
(3 Firsts/14)
|
Dave
Hingstman, Iowa |
27 |
(1 First/9)
|
Ross
Smith, Wake Forest |
21 |
(2 Firsts/7)
|
If one characteristic has
come through with the Best of the 1980s compared with the Best of the
1970s it is the growing importance of the NDT, or perhaps increased
recognition of its changing and improving structure. In the Best of
the 1970s the best team never won the NDT or even reached the semi-finals,
the NDT itself finished a poor third among Best Tournaments; but the
Best of the 1980s reflects a consistent acceptance of the NDT results
as being a meaningful indicator for the year.
|
Reprinted
from: Allan D. Louden and William Southworth, eds. "The 50th National
Debate Tournament." Winston-Salem, NC: Wake Forest University, 1996
|